Is it Fish or Frankenfish?

Tell the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to put a label on all genetically engineered salmon. Without the label consumers won’t know whether or not they’re eating genetically modified salmon.

The devil is in the details: In genetically engineered food, the DNA from one organism is placed into another and interferes with the structure and/or function of the animal. The salmon would get a growth gene from the Pacific chinook salmon and genetic material from the ocean pout, an eel-like fish, that would allow the salmon to grow in the summer and winter speeding up the natural growth process.

I don’t want a little eel with my salmon thanks very much. And, I don’t need my fish to grow to full size overnight. What I eat should be my choice and my choice alone. Without a warning label choice is taken away.

There’s an informative video produced by CNN: Eat Genetically-Altered Food?

Let’s be smart. Insist genetically engineered salmon require a warning label. Sign the petition ‘Tell the FDA: Put a Label on Genetically Engineered Salmon.’

28 responses to “Is it Fish or Frankenfish?”

  1. Oh crap, they NEED to label this stuff. Question – what about fish that’s bought at a fish counter? How would they label that?

  2. Melanie @ Frugal Kiwi

    Here in New Zealand, GMOs are not allowed, so I can’t imagine not even being TOLD that a food is GMO so you can make your own choices. Shocking.

  3. MarthaandMe

    Kind of scary, but where is the line? They breed other animals to enhance certain qualities. This seems like a totally different thing though.

  4. Tweets that mention Is it Fish or Frankenfish? -- Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Stephanie Stiavetti and Brette Sember, Judith Stock. Judith Stock said: Would you eat genetically altered salmon? Is it Fish or Frankenfish? http://bit.ly/9yOoUq #FDA #salmon #food #gmo [...]

  5. Roxanne @ Champion of My Heart

    Sometimes I feel like there isn’t anything a girl can safely eat.

    1. Casey@Good. Food. Stories.

      Roxanne, I feel the same way – I hate to admit it, but I’ve been avoiding the fish counter because I’m just overwhelmed by everything I should be avoiding. And my local Whole Foods doesn’t stock too much that’s on the green list! So sad.

  6. Alexandra Grabbe

    This makes me furious. We are discussing salmon here, but ALL genetically modified organisms should be labeled, and we should have the choice to eat food that is not genetically modified. We are talking nutrition, too. Apparently gm crops are less nutritious and lab animals in Europe that have been fed a diet of gm crops lose their ability to reproduce. As for the salmon, I do not want to eat it, and I want to know how to avoid it. There’s a new petition on Facebook with this regard. I will add the link here for your readers, and head over to sign the petition you posted. Thanks for this report! http://www.causes.com/causes/270

  7. Alexandra Grabbe

    PS. Just discovered this article on the subject, which is sure to interest you: http://www.anh-usa.org/genetically-engineered-foods-and-new-action-alert/. If it was just me, I would not be so upset, but all this craziness in food politics and limited choices in food and possible consequences of eating only gmos is worrisome because I’m a grandmother now.

  8. Christine

    How infuriating indeed, that consumers don’t get a choice. Thank you for alerting us to this issue!

  9. MyKidsEatSquid

    I’ve heard somewhere that Trader Joe’s isn’t allowing GMOs, do you know if that’s true?

  10. I think truth in labeling would be a nice thing. I understand that manufacturers are against it because they worry we would change our buying habits. Well, duh. That’s the whole point, now, isn’t it?

  11. Alexandra Grabbe

    The educated ones are ALREADY changing their buying habits.

    And, regarding Trader Joe’s, not everyone has a Trader Joe’s nearby. I have to drive 45 minutes to reach one. I applaud their policy, but soon it will be impossible to be sure crops are not GMOs because of drift, gmo seeds are taking over. Food Inc. shows how small farmers are being sued by Monsanto when this happens and made to go out of business. Soon it will be impossible to plant non-GMO seeds, as Monsanto is buying up all the seed companies.

  12. Yes, we absolutely need to know what we are eating, especially something that is altered from its original state. Thanks for bringing this to our attention – especially mine, since salmon is the one fish I eat the most.

  13. This is a huge pet peeve of mine. I want to know so that *I* can make an informed decision about what I buy and eat. And while salmon is problematic, we need labeling on ALL of our foods. Who’s in charge of what we eat? Us or them?

  14. sarah henry

    Absolutely, a label is called for. Thanks for alerting me to the latest on the fish front. I find the whole fishing quandary so complex that I’m eating fewer and fewer ocean creatures ’cause I’m uncertain what’s okay and what isn’t for a host of eco and health reasons.

  15. Merr

    My feeling is…if it’s the SAME then what’s to hide? You’d think they’d want to be promoting this, you know?

  16. Wow this is a great resource.. I’m enjoying it.. good article

  17. Really informative post. And I agree that a label that informs the consumer what they’re about to purchase is necessary. Only then can they make informed decisions.
    Jeanine